Bot activity can make your reports look better than they are, and acting on those numbers can hurt your deliverability. Security scanners and other automated systems can register clicks and opens that no person made. If you build dynamic lists or judge a campaign on those numbers, you can end up sending again to the recipients whose systems are scrutinizing your mail, instead of the subscribers who want it.
Sending to engaged subscribers helps build your sender reputation and earn trust with mailbox providers/ISPs. That trust leads to more consistent inbox placement. A smaller, more engaged list tends to deliver better ROI and stronger inbox placement, which in turn leads to more authentic click and open rates. Filtering out bot activity gives you cleaner data to decide who to send to next.
What bot click and open filtering does
Bot filtering removes clicks and opens that look automated from your reporting and dynamic list rules (which can be used to start automations), so your numbers reflect real subscriber activity more closely.
It works by checking activity against a set of key indicators that have previously been tied to non-human clicks and opens. Activity that matches those indicators is filtered out. A summary of the rules appears later in this article.
What counts as a bot
In this article, a bot is an automated system, such as a security scanner or link checker, that opens a message or follows its links without a person doing it. These tools can be deployed by the recipient's domain, by a mailbox provider (ISP), or by an individual subscriber. Automated activity can show up at several points:
| When it happens | Who may be checking | What you may see in reports |
|---|---|---|
| Before delivery | A company's firewall or email security gateway | Links followed to look for malware |
| While the message is being handled | A mailbox provider | URLs checked for phishing |
| At click time | A link-protection service run by the recipient's organization | A link tested again when a subscriber clicks, or on its own |
| In the inbox | A privacy feature in the email app | Message content preloaded, which can register as an open |
What filtering does not do
Filtering does not stop the clicks from happening. It only removes bot activity from your reporting and from dynamic list rules. If click tracking is enabled, bot traffic still reaches the landing pages your links point to, so it may still show up in your website analytics.
Filtering also applies only to new activity. It does not change jobs you have already sent.
How accurate it is
Some filtering rules can flag human activity as bot-like when it follows a similar pattern. The risk is low, but by enabling the feature you accept it in exchange for cleaner engagement data.
How bot activity affects your campaigns
Bot activity does more than clutter a report. Because it looks like real engagement, it can quietly steer decisions about your content, your lists, and your budget.
Inflated performance numbers
When automated systems open or click your messages, your open and click rates rise without any added interest from subscribers. A campaign with ordinary results can look like a standout, which hides how your content and offers are really performing.
Misleading A/B tests
Bots can decide a test for you. Suppose you compare two call-to-action buttons, and one version happens to reach more recipients who sit behind strict corporate security tools. Those tools click the links automatically, that version looks like the winner, and you carry the wrong lesson into later campaigns.
Dynamic lists and automations built on false activity
Dynamic lists that group contacts by clicks or opens can pull in contacts who never engaged. When those lists start automations, people receive follow-up messages because of activity a machine produced.
Return on investment you cannot trust
If bot clicks make up a large share of your clicks, you cannot tie clicks to results with confidence. Your cost to win a customer can be higher than your reports suggest, and you may keep funding tactics that are not paying off.
Signs of bot activity
You can often spot bot activity in your own reports before filtering is turned on. These patterns are clues, not proof, so look for more than one.
| What you see | Where to look | Why it points to automation |
|---|---|---|
| Clicks arrive within moments of sending, sometimes at odd hours | Click report, by time | Scanners tend to act as soon as a message arrives, while people read on their own schedule. |
| Many clicks but few visits to your site | Email clicks compared with web analytics | Scanners may fetch a link without running your page's analytics, so the two numbers disagree. |
| Many clicks but few sign-ups, purchases, or form submissions | Clicks compared with conversions | Automated clicks do not convert. |
| One contact clicks every link in a message, including the logo and unsubscribe link | Contact-level click activity | Scanners test every link. A person usually clicks one or two. |
| Several clicks in the same second, or from different IP addresses within seconds | Click export with timestamps and IPs | This is how automated checks move through a message. |
| The same contact does the same thing in every message | Contact activity across campaigns | Scripts repeat themselves, while people vary. |
| Clickers land at your site and stay for only a fraction of a seond | Google analytics or site reporting | Bots check to see if the link is legitimately completed, not what is at the site |
Summary of the filtering rules
Filtering checks click and open activity against a set of behavior rules, and activity that matches is removed from your reporting and dynamic list rules. In plain terms, the rules look for:
- Several actions at once: multiple clicks from the same contact within one second.
- Several IP addresses: one contact's activity coming from more than one IP address in a short window.
- Broad link coverage: one contact clicking many of a message's links within moments.
- Several user agents: one contact's activity coming from more than one email client or browser signature.
- Immediate activity: a click or open within moments of sending, or a click from an IP address before the message was delivered.
- Bot traps: activity on links placed to catch automated systems.
Because the rules are based on behavior, human activity that happens to match these patterns can be filtered too.
How to enable bot click and open filtering
You can turn on bot click and open filtering yourself for each sub account, or ask Critical Impact support to do it. Filtering is set per sub account, so repeat the process for every sub account you want covered.
Option 1: Ask support to enable it (for clients without sub accounts)
Use this option if your account does not have sub accounts, or if you would rather have our team make the change. Email support to enable bot click filtering. The subject line is filled in for you. Add the following details to the message:
- Account Name:
- Sub Account Name (if applicable):
- Should this be enabled ASAP?
Support typically completes the request within a few business days.
Option 2: Enable it yourself (available only for clients with sub accounts)
- Go to Sub Account Admin > Edit/Add Company.
- Double-click the sub account you want to update.
- Click the + button to expand the Advanced Options section, then check the box next to Enable Spam Bot Click Filter.
- Click Save button.
- Repeat these steps for each additional sub account.
How to turn off bot click and open filtering
Turning the filter off is also a support request. Email support to disable bot click filtering with the same details you would use to enable it. Support typically completes the request within a few business days.
Turning the filter off stops filtering of new activity. Activity that was already filtered stays filtered.
How to reduce the impact of bot activity
Filtering helps, but a few habits keep bot activity from skewing your reports and lists in the first place.
- Keep your list clean. Regularly remove invalid, inactive, and suspicious addresses. A tidy list protects your sender reputation with mailbox providers and leaves less noise in your reports.
- Use dynamic lists to flag suspicious patterns. Build a dynamic list of contacts whose activity looks automated, for example contacts who click every link in a message. Review the list before you act on it, because some of those contacts may be real people.
- Adjust how often you send to contacts you are unsure about. Rather than removing them outright, consider sending them less often and watching whether their activity changes.
Comments
0 comments
Please sign in to leave a comment.